Nolan Arenado
- 10× Rawlings Gold Glove Award (Third Base, 2013-2022) Wikipedia+2MLB.com+2
- 6× Rawlings Platinum Glove Award (Defensive Player of the Year, NL, 2017-2022) MLB.com+2Wikipedia+2
- 5× Silver Slugger Award (Third Base, 2015-2018, 2022) Wikipedia+2Baseball Almanac+2
- 8× MLB All-Star selection (2015–2019, 2021–2023) Wikipedia+1
- 3× NL Home Run Leader (2015, 2016, 2018) Wikipedia
- 2× NL Runs Batted In (RBI) Leader (2015, 2016) Wikipedia
- Fielding Bible Award (Third Base) – multiple years (2015–2017, 2020) Baseball Almanac
- Wilson Defensive Player of the Year (Third Base) – multiple years (2015–2017) Baseball Almanac
- Arizona Fall League Joe Black MVP (2011) Baseball Almanac
- Colorado Sports Hall of Fame – Professional Athlete of the Year (2015) Baseball Almanac
